Intraspecific and interspecific variation in prickly poppy resistance to non-native generalist caterpillars

Jacob Suissa, Kasey Barton


Background: Prickly poppies (genus Argemone, Papaveraceae) epitomize well-defended plants. With high prickle densities and exudation of bright yellow latex from glaucous leaves, there are few reports of herbivore damage on these plants. Yet, little ecological work has examined within-plant or among-species variation in levels of anti-herbivore defenses in prickly poppies.

Questions: Are prickly poppies well defended against generalist herbivores? Does chemical defense vary within prickly poppy plants in a pattern consistent with optimal defense theory?

Species study: Argemone glauca, A. mexicana, A. ochroleuca, A. platyceras were examined in bioassays using generalist caterpillars, Agrotis ipsilon Hufnagel and Chrysodeixis eriosoma Doubleday (Noctuidae).

Study sites and dates: Seeds were collected from field populations in Mexico (2015) and Hawaii (2011); experiment was conducted at the University of Hawaii at Manoa, Fall 2015.

Methods: Using a pair of no-choice bioassays, variation in the quality of whole-leaf and chemical extract infused artificial diets for caterpillar development was assessed.

Results: Survivorship was lowest on the control lettuce diet, and varied little between poppy diets although pupal mass was marginally lower for caterpillars reared on A. platyceras than A. ochroleuca. Isolating the effects of plant chemistry, C. eriosoma performance was most strongly reduced by seed extracts, with an extension in pupal development time by one week compared to herbivores reared on other diets, as well as a significant reduction in mean adult mass.

Conclusions: These results are consistent with optimal defense theory, reflecting greater allocation of defense in tissues of high fitness value (i.e., seeds). Future work with native herbivores, chemical analyses, and investigations into alternative functions for these plant traits would shed new light on this interesting group of plants.


plant-herbivore interactions; plant defense; no-choice bioassay; prickles; latex

Full Text:

Full Text PDF


Agrawal, A. A. and M. Fishbein. 2006. Plant defense syndromes. Ecology 87:S132-S149.

Agrawal, A. A., M. Fishbein, R. Jetter, J. P. Salminen, J. B. Goldstein, A. E. Freitag, and J. P. Sparks. 2009. Phylogenetic ecology of leaf surface traits in the milkweeds (Asclepias spp.): chemistry, ecophysiology, and insect behavior. New Phytologist 183:848-867.

Agrawal, A. A. and K. Konno. 2009. Latex: A Model for Understanding Mechanisms, Ecology, and Evolution of Plant Defense Against Herbivory. Annual Review of Ecology Evolution and Systematics 40:311-331.

Ali, J. G. and A. A. Agrawal. 2012. Specialist versus generalist insect herbivores and plant defense. Trends in Plant Science 17:293-302.

Ansari, K. M., L. K. S. Chauhan, A. Dhawan, S. K. Khanna, and M. Das. 2004. Unequivocal evidence of genotoxic potential of argemone oil in mice. International Journal of Cancer 112:890-895.

Barton, K. E. 2014. Prickles, latex and tolerance in the endemic Hawaiian prickly poppy (Argemone glauca): Variation between populations, across ontogeny and due to phenotypic plasticity. Oecologia 174:1273-1281.

Bell, A. D. and A. Bryan. 2008. Plant Form: An Illustrated Guide to Flowering Plant Morphology. New Edition edition. Timber Press, London.

Bennett, R. N. and R. M. Wallsgrove. 1994. Secondary metabolites in plant defense - mechanisms. New Phytologist 127:617-633.

Benrey, B. and R. F. Denno. 1997. The slow-growth-high-mortality hypothesis: A test using the cabbage butterfly. Ecology 78:987-999.

Brahmachari, G., D. Gorai, and R. Roy. 2013. Argemone mexicana: chemical and pharmacological aspects. Brazilian Journal of Pharmacognosy 23:559-575.

Briand, C. H. and C. L. Soros. 2001. Spatial variation of prickle abundance on leaves of the devil's walking stick (Aralia spinosa; Araliaceae) during the trunk-building phase. Journal of the Torrey Botanical Society 128:219-225.

Capasso, A., S. Piacente, C. Pizza, N. De Tommasi, C. Jativa, and L. Sorrentino. 1997. Isoquinoline alkaloids from Argemone mexicana reduce morphine withdrawal in Guinea Pig isolated ileum. Planta Medica 63:326-328.

Carlquist, S. J. 1970. Hawai'i: A Natural History. 2nd edition. Pacific Tropical Botanical Garden, Lawai, Kaua’i, Hawai’i.

Chang, Y. C., F. R. Chang, A. T. Khalil, P. W. Hsieh, and Y. C. Wu. 2003. Cytotoxic benzophenanthridine and benzylisoquinoline alkaloids from Argemone mexicana. Zeitschrift Fur Naturforschung C-a Journal of Biosciences 58:521-526.

Clancy, K. M. and P. W. Price. 1987. Rapid herbivore growth enhances enemy attack: sublethal plant defences remain a paradox. Ecology 68:736-738.

Ehrlich, P. R. and P. H. Raven. 1964. Butterflies and plants: a study in coevolution. Evolution 18:586-608.

Eigenbrode, S. D. and K. E. Espelie. 1995. Effects of plant epicuticular lipids on insect herbivores. Annual Review of Entomology 40:171-194.

Fricke, E. C., D. C. Haak, D. J. Levey, and J. J. Tewksbury. 2016. Gut passage and secondary metabolites alter the source of post-dispersal predation for bird-dispersed chili seeds. Oecologia 181:905-910.

Fritz, R. S. and E. L. Simms, editors. 1992. Plant Resistance to Herbivores and Pathogens. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

Givnish, T. J., K. J. Sytsma, J. F. Smith, and W. J. Hahn. 1994. Thorn-like prickles and heterophylly in Cyanea - adaptations to extinct avian browsers on Hawai'i. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 91:2810-2814.

Goeden, R. D. and D. W. Ricker. 1985. Prickly poppies, Argemone corymbosa and Argemone munita, in Southern California - native weeds attacked by few insects. Annals of the Entomological Society of America 78:214-216.

Grubb, P. J. 1992. A positive distrust in simplicity - lessons from plant defenses and from competition among plants and among animals. Journal of Ecology 80:585-610.

Guizar-Gonzalez, C., K. Trujillo-Villanueva, M. Monforte-Gonzalez, and F. Vazquez-Flota. 2012. Sanguinarine and dihydrosanguinarine accumulation in Argemone mexicana (L) cell suspension cultures exposed to yeast extract. Journal of the Mexican Chemical Society 56:19-22.

Hanley, M. E., B. B. Lamont, M. M. Fairbanks, and C. M. Rafferty. 2007. Plant structural traits and their role in anti-herbivore defence. Perspectives in Plant Ecology, Evolution and Systematics 8:157-178.

Hoan, R., R. Ormond, and K. E. Barton. 2014. Prickly poppies can get pricklier: ontogenetic patterns in the induction of physical defense traits. Plos One 9:E96796.

Honek, A. 1993. Intraspecific variation in body size and fecundity in insects - a general relationship. Oikos 66:483-492.

Huang, T. F., G. Jander, and M. de Vos. 2011. Non-protein amino acids in plant defense against insect herbivores: Representative cases and opportunities for further functional analysis. Phytochemistry 72:1531-1537.

James, H. F. and D. A. Burney. 1997. The diet and ecology of Hawaii's extinct flightless waterfowl: evidence from coprolites. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 62:279-297.

Jordan, G. J., R. A. Dillon, and P. H. Weston. 2005. Solar radiation as a factor in the evolution of scleromorphic leaf anatomy in Proteaceae. American Journal of Botany 92:789-796.

Karban, R. and A. A. Agrawal. 2002. Herbivore offense. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 33:641-664.

Kariyat, R. R. and S. L. Portman. 2016. Plant-herbivore interactions: Thinking beyond larval growth and mortality. American Journal of Botany 103:789-791.

Konstantopoulou, E., G. Kapotis, G. Salachas, S. A. Petropoulos, I. C. Karapanos, and H. C. Passam. 2010. Nutritional quality of greenhouse lettuce at harvest and after storage in relation to N application and cultivation season. Scientia Horticulturae 125:93-94.

Koricheva, J., H. Nykanen, and E. Gianoli. 2004. Meta-analysis of trade-offs among plant antiherbivore defenses: Are plants jacks-of-all-trades, masters of all? American Naturalist 163:E64-E75.

Liakopoulos, G., D. Nikolopoulos, A. Klouvatou, K. A. Vekkos, Y. Manetas, and G. Karabourniotis. 2006. The photoprotective role of epidermal anthocyanins and surface pubescence in young leaves of grapevine (Vitis vinifera). Annals of Botany 98:257-265.

Liu, Y. Q., X. W. Fu, L. M. Mao, Z. L. Xing, and K. M. Wu. 2016. Host Plants Identification for Adult Agrotis ipsilon, a Long-Distance Migratory Insect. International Journal of Molecular Sciences 17.

Luther, G. C., H. R. Valenzuela, and J. Defrank. 1996. Impact of cruciferous trap crops on lepidopteran pests of cabbage in Hawaii. Environmental Entomology 25:39-47.

McCall, A. C. and J. A. Fordyce. 2010. Can optimal defence theory be used to predict the distribution of plant chemical defences? Journal of Ecology 98:985-992.

McKey, D. 1979. The distribution of secondary compounds within plants. Pages 55-133 in G. A. Rosenthal and D. H. Janzen, editors. Herbivores: Their interactions with secondary plant metabolites. Academic Press, New York.

Meléndez, P. A. and V. A. Capriles. 2002. Molluscicidal activity of plants from Puerto Rico. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 96:209-218.

Oliveira, A. F. M., S. T. Meirelles, and A. Salatino. 2003. Epicuticular waxes from caatinga and cerrado species and their efficiency against water loss. Anais Da Academia Brasileira De Ciencias 75:431-439.

Osho, A. and T. Adetunji. 2010. Antimicrobial activity of the essential oil of Argemone mexicana Linn. Journal of Medicinal Plants Research 4:19-22.

Potter, D. A. and T. W. Kimmerer. 1988. Do holly leaf spines really deter herbivory? Oecologia 75:216-221.

Reyes, F. D., C. J. Peña, M. Canales, M. Jiménez, S. Meráz, and T. Hernandez. 2011. Antimicrobial activity of Argemone ochroleuca Sweet (Chicalote). Boletin Latinoamericano Y Del Caribe De Plantas Medicinales Y Aromaticas 10:139-146.

Saeki, Y. and P. Crowley. 2012. Temperature effects during development on a polyembryonic parasitoid and its host. Journal of Thermal Biology 37:602-607.

Sakthivadivel, M. and D. Thilagavathy. 2003. Larvicidal and chemosterilant activity of the acetone fraction of petroleum ether extract from Argemone mexicana L. seed. Bioresource Technology 89:213-216.

Scholz, I., M. Buckins, L. Dolge, T. Erlinghagen, A. Weth, F. Hischen, J. Mayer, S. Hoffmann, M. Riederer, M. Riedel, and W. Baumgartner. 2010. Slippery surfaces of pitcher plants: Nepenthes wax crystals minimize insect attachment via microscopic surface roughness. Journal of Experimental Biology 213:1115-1125.

Schreiber, L. and M. Riederer. 1996. Determination of diffusion coefficients of octadecanoic acid in isolated cuticular waxes and their relationship to cuticular water permeabilities. Plant Cell and Environment 19:1075-1082.

Schwarzbach, A. E. and J. W. Kadereit. 1999. Phylogeny of prickly poppies, Argemone (Papaveraceae), and the evolution of morphological and alkaloid characters based on ITS nrDNA sequence variation. Plant Systematics and Evolution 218:257-279.

Shaukat, S. S., I. A. Siddiqui, G. H. Khan, and M. J. Zaki. 2002. Nematicidal and allelopathic potential of Argemone mexicana, a tropical weed - Allelopathic and nematicidal potential of Argemone mexicana. Plant and Soil 245:239-247.

Singer, M. S., T. E. Farkas, C. M. Skorik, and K. A. Mooney. 2012. Tritrophic Interactions at a Community Level: Effects of Host Plant Species Quality on Bird Predation of Caterpillars. American Naturalist 179:363-374.

Singh, S., T. D. Singh, V. P. Singh, and V. B. Pandey. 2010. A new benzylisoquinoline alkaloid from Argemone mexicana. Natural Product Research 24:63-67.

Smilanich, A. M., R. M. Fincher, and L. A. Dyer. 2016. Does plant apparency matter? Thirty years of data provide limited support but reveal clear patterns of the effects of plant chemistry on herbivores. New Phytologist.

Verma, S. K., G. Dev, A. K. Tyagi, S. Goomber, and G. V. Jain. 2001. Argemone mexicana poisoning: autopsy findings of two cases. Forensic Science International 115:135-141.

Wagner, W. L., D. R. Herbst, and S. H. Sohmer. 1999. Manual of the Flowering Plants of Hawai'i. Revised edition. University of Hawai'i Press, Bishop Museum Press, Honolulu.

Xu, C. M., Z. Q. Zhang, K. D. Cui, Y. H. Zhao, J. K. Han, F. Liu, and W. Mu. 2016. Effects of sublethal concentrations of cyantraniliprole on the development, fecundity and nutritional physiology of the black cutworm Agrotis ipsilon ( Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). Plos One 11.

Ziegler, A. C. 2002. Hawaiian Natural History, Ecology, and Evolution. University of Hawai'i Press, Honolulu.



  • There are currently no refbacks.

ISSN: 2007-4476
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.